Ninth Circuit splits California’s climate disclosure laws
California’s first corporate emissions reporting deadline has passed as planned, but two other parts of the state’s climate disclosure regime are now in doubt. These are codified in two senate bills, or SBs. A divided panel of the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled a day before the 10 November deadline under the Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act (SB 253). It let Scope 1 and 2 reporting proceed, but found Scope 3 reporting, and the climate-risk reports required by SB 261 (Greenhouse gases: climate-related financial risk), likely to be unconstitutional.
The dividing line for the court is ownership. Emissions from a company’s own operations and purchased energy bear on capital-market transactions, the majority held, so requiring their disclosure regulates commercial speech, which states have more room to compel. In Judge Jacqueline Nguyen’s words, “emissions disclosures function like product warnings in capital markets.” Scope 3, on the other hand, concerns the conduct of third parties across the value chain. The court placed it outside commercial speech, where a stricter test applies that the state is unlikely to meet. SB 261’s reports, based on the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) framework, face the same test because the court found they demand predictive and politically fraught judgments.
The ruling is preliminary. The district court must now decide whether Scope 3 can be severed from the rest of SB 253, and either side may seek a rehearing. SB 261 has been on hold since the same court paused it in November 2025, and the California Air Resources Board (CARB) had already pushed the first SB 253 deadline back from August.
For now, the court’s message to regulators is that the numbers a company produces about itself can be required in much the same way as financial data, while data about its value chain is on weaker ground from a legal perspective. Nothing constrains corporates working with their supply chains to provide Scope 3 information on a voluntary basis.
Read the opinion here.

